Good thing MC won't be winning. ;)
Think about last time we disagreed on a debatable match. Good. Remember what happened last time? That will happen again.
---
The topic is dead. Not the kind of dead that can be cured with a Phoenix Down. I'm talking FMV sequence dead.- The King in Teal
Don't forget the fact that Master Chief fluctuated too. Doing piss-poor against Felix to getting a respectable number on a Final Fantasy 7 character.
---
The topic is dead. Not the kind of dead that can be cured with a Phoenix Down. I'm talking FMV sequence dead.- The King in Teal
Wow. I've been wrong once in a debatable match, I guess that means you'll always be right and I'll always be wrong.
---
SC2k4 Winner: Mega Man
Ken Masters; the fighting king clothed in blazing fire.
Well, Master Chief only seemed to fluctuate because Felix overperformed. You saw his true strength against Aeris.
---
Bomberman's Road to the Summer Championship
1st Round: (4)Squall Leonhart, 2nd Round: (5)Kirby
It pisses me off to no end when people try to use that when discussing matches by the way.
---
SC2k4 Winner: Mega Man
Ken Masters; the fighting king clothed in blazing fire.
I remember the last time Heroic Mario and I disagreed about a match and he was right. Seems like only yesterday...
---
Bomberman's Road to the Summer Championship
1st Round: (4)Squall Leonhart, 2nd Round: (5)Kirby
It pisses me off to no end when people try to use that when discussing matches by the way.
I was actually just using it jokingly as a way to say, "I'm right so =P to you."
---
The topic is dead. Not the kind of dead that can be cured with a Phoenix Down. I'm talking FMV sequence dead.- The King in Teal
I wish I could be that confident in Frog...
---
Snake vs. Tanner - http://www.stripcreator.com/comics/Moltar
Tommy vs Zero - Bracket: Zero - Vote: Zero (40/42)
I remember the last time Heroic Mario and I disagreed about a match and he was right. Seems like only yesterday...
XDDDDDDD
---
M-me? Queen ***** of the Universe?
This is the happiest day of my life. ~ smitelf
Well, I couldn't tell you were using it in a joking way. I've gotten crap from Joe vs Tails so much that I can't stand hearing it anymore when a discussion on a match pops up. People act as if my credibility is totally shot because I've been wrong once. Thankfully, I think yesterday got it all back.
---
SC2k4 Winner: Mega Man
Ken Masters; the fighting king clothed in blazing fire.
With all of this said, Frog is kickin' some ass tomorrow. GameFAQs needs to pull through and get one of the best characters in this contest through to the next round. =p
---
SC2k4 Winner: Mega Man
Ken Masters; the fighting king clothed in blazing fire.
Well I would give a lengthy analysis as to why I think MC would win but I'm not in the mood. If I do later it will be my first ever analysis ^_^
---
The topic is dead. Not the kind of dead that can be cured with a Phoenix Down. I'm talking FMV sequence dead.- The King in Teal
Yeah, we need to make sure Squall advances to round 2 here in a few days.
---
Bomberman's Road to the Summer Championship
1st Round: (4)Squall Leonhart, 2nd Round: (5)Kirby
Master Chief can and will come through tomorrow!
and to TWW question, even if the graphics had been better, it wouldn't have risen to the popularity to beat ff7. The graphics may have been very offputting, and gave WW a bad picture overall to start with, but had the game been extremely good, it could have recovered. Graphics are an important part of games, and if a games got bad graphics, it can't really help. WW was good, I loved the whole
*SPOILERS*
hyrule being gone thing, and also the King dying at the end. A bit morose though to be ridfing around in his corpse though...
END
---
Today's Survivor topic can be found here, Please vote : )http://boards.gamefaqs.com/gfaqs/genmessage.php?board=8&topic=16070956
I wish I could be that confident in Frog...
Does he know the meaning of not being confident? ;)
---
M-me? Queen ***** of the Universe?
This is the happiest day of my life. ~ smitelf
I gave my analysis of the Frog/Master Chief matchup a few pages back, but I didn't officially call it an "analysis". I mentioned a few key points though.
About Wind Waker. I actually liked it BETTER than OoT. LttP is my definite favorite. The story in WW was much better than OoT, and the game play was better too. I know the gameplay was BASED off of OoT, but that means it is SUPPOSED to be better. Sailing wasn't THAT bad. The most annoying part of sailing was having to change the wind every time you wanted to make a turn or U-turn. If they would have had something like having the C-stick instantly turning the wind, it would have been more tolerable. Oh yeah, and having to treasure hunt all the time got pretty old too. I don't think the graphics hurt it at all as a GAME (it may hurt Link). I think people complained about the graphics because they didn't like the way that Link looked. Those that don't like the graphics probably haven't even played it. The first thing I said when I first played it was "the animation is amazing!". If they would have upped the difficulty and the length (more dungeons, better bosses), it would easily have been my favorite Zelda game.
---
"There are only 10 kinds of people in this world, those that read binary and those that don't."
A somewhat underwhelming performance from Zero here.
Oh, and Frog is in trouble. BIG trouble. He's not even that great a character...he has a nice musical theme, but his character design is VERY lame. I now expect MC to win tomorrow.
---
"Thank you, Mario. But our princess is in another castle."
-Toad in Super Mario Bros.
A somewhat underwhelming performance from Zero here.
Right around what he should have gotten. Not like he's doing anything shocking either way.
Oh, and Frog is in trouble. BIG trouble. He's not even that great a character...he has a nice musical theme, but his character design is VERY lame. I now expect MC to win tomorrow.
Frog kicks ass on many, many different levels with that musical tune being one of them. And please explain how he's in "BIG trouble".
---
SC2k4 Winner: Mega Man
Ken Masters; the fighting king clothed in blazing fire.
It's disgusting to see how many people on this board change their opinions so much. Whatever happened to "Anyone who doesn't look at a sword-wielding amphibian in awe should question their purpose in this mortal coil"? :P (Not calling you out Ulti, just talking about the hype that you brought in saying that.)
It will be a close match, but to those bringing up all the "new" characters such as Ryu Hayabusa, Viewtiful Joe, and Jak being overrated and not doing what they were supposed to, why haven't you brought up Vivi? If Vivi can give Donkey Kong a 56/44 beating, why are people saying Frog is in big trouble? Frog should be more comparable to Vivi than he is to Joe. Ryu, Joe, and Jak each brought a new SERIES to the contest. Chrono Trigger is already established. Metal Gear was already established. Have you forgotten that Squaresoft voters will almost ALWAYS support their own? Frog still has a very decent chance in this match.
Not detracting from Master Chief any in this post... he's legit as well.
---
"There are only 10 kinds of people in this world, those that read binary and those that don't."
Vivi probably could've done better if he had had 65% of the brackets on his side. =/
---
M-me? Queen ***** of the Universe?
This is the happiest day of my life. ~ smitelf
I now expect MC to win tomorrow.
I've been expecting MC to win since his performance over Crash. My bracket has had ample bracing time for an upcoming pwnage, and is used to it by now.
---
Jon Thomson - today: Zero, tomorrow: Frog - 34/42
Nominate Ridley for Summer Contest 2005
Vivi did as well as Auron last year without SFF adjustments, which was still quite good. Don't put more than the customer asks.
I just read through Ulti's PCA, and by God, the way his Halo/Starcraft preview was written... let's just say that if he could smash Chief's chances tomorrow like that everyone would be all over Frog by now.
Whatever happened to that new Syphon Filter anyway? Did it bomb like Ulti hoped? ;)
---
SC2K4 Status - Points: 040/042 - Matches: 35/37 - Rank: 00116/33221 - Today: Zero - Tomorrow: Frog
Vivi did as well as Auron last year without SFF adjustments, which was still quite good. Don't put more than the customer asks.
Bah. =(
I just read through Ulti's PCA, and by God, the way his Halo/Starcraft preview was written... let's just say that if he could smash Chief's chances tomorrow like that everyone would be all over Frog by now.
He'll have a field day next year with Ganondorf. He'll get every single person who IMs him about a bracket to put some random fodder character over Ganondorf... heh.
Whatever happened to that new Syphon Filter anyway? Did it bomb like Ulti hoped? ;)
Probably... HM?
---
M-me? Queen ***** of the Universe?
This is the happiest day of my life. ~ smitelf
You mean, like the guy who IMed him and he persuaded him to put Zero over Megaman?
Speaking of which, Zero's looking better with the evening vote, something I fail to understand.
Still, I get the feeling Megaman is going to send parts of him to the junk pile, and the rest back to the pr0n drawing board. I wonder how that dude from the first paragraph must be feeling right now.
---
SC2K4 Status - Points: 040/042 - Matches: 35/37 - Rank: 00116/33221 - Today: Zero - Tomorrow: Frog
I wish i can also be that confident in a Frog victory but i can seriously see Master Chief pulling this off with not just a win but rather a "convincing" win.. Or i can just be completely off and be owned by Frog with a convincing win over Master Chief..
As for the TWW comment.. Even if the graphics were better, there's no way it would have gotten past Final Fantasy VII.. The TWW was probably the weakest of LoZ with OoT being on top and LttP being right behind than WW..
SORRY CHICHIRI, i don't mean to offend you or anything but Characters does not equal Games in terms of strength and popularity. It does for some but not for all.. I am pretty sure that Final Fantasy VII stands a few notches above Cloud Strife and Sephiroth.. I just don't see how it can be taken down this coming Spring Contest..
---
SC2K4 Winner: Cloud Strife
Next Target: Vyse
SORRY CHICHIRI, i don't mean to offend you or anything but Characters does not equal Games in terms of strength and popularity.
Did you read what he wrote? O_o
He said that he knew that already; he was one of the first people who was pointing that out and doesn't need to be lectured about it...
---
M-me? Queen ***** of the Universe?
This is the happiest day of my life. ~ smitelf
Two questions regarding the spring contest:
One, does anyone have a link to Ulti's post contest analysis?
Two, if someone DID bring FFVII down in the next spring contest, what game would it be?
I don't see any games from the spring contest gaining enough to take down FFVII. Someone already pointed out that games are different from characters in the fact that characters may fluctuate in popularity from year to year, as games are pretty much stable. I agree with that. FFVII may get beat in the FUTURE, but I don't see it happening next year, unless the new Zelda blows everybody's mind. I do think that FFVII would be more vulnerable if the bracket was mixed up, but I don't see any of the returning games outright taking it down next year. 3-4 years from now? An entirely different story....
---
"There are only 10 kinds of people in this world, those that read binary and those that don't."
I'd also find it harder for a game to fluctuate in popularity, especially ones that aren't exactly brand-new. The only way I could see Final Fantasy 7 losing is if a new game comes out that completely owns or a game that didn't make it in, but isn't new beats it.
Not to say that'd we'd even get another game contest in the spring, but if we do I demand Mega Man get one title at least in there. Oh and none of that division by era.
---
SC2k4 Winner: Mega Man
Ken Masters; the fighting king clothed in blazing fire.
Not to say that'd we'd even get another game contest in the spring, but if we do I demand Mega Man get one title at least in there. Oh and none of that division by era.
Agreed.. Megaman X anyone?
---
SC2K4 Winner: Cloud Strife
Next Target: Vyse
Heroic Mario, I left you an opening to come in and say that a Mega Man game would enter and take down FFVII. :P
Seriously, if Mega Man 2 and Mega Man X aren't in next years contest, I will be HIGHLY upset. Hmmmm, would MMAC have been eligible to be in Division 128?
Oh yeah, still waiting on the PCA link....
---
"There are only 10 kinds of people in this world, those that read binary and those that don't."
I don't think that a best game ever contest would really work if we did it every year. I think it would work better as an every 2 or 3 year thing, simply because we wouldn't get enough new blood in every year.
---
Summer Contest Match 38 Zero vs Tommy
Status 33/36 Points: 037 Next: Master Chief vs. FROG!!!!!
Mega Man 2 would lay some damage onto the game that is Final Fantasy 7. Just goes without saying. ;)
If MMAC were eligible for the 128 division I'd imagine Sonic Mega Collection, Zelda Collector's Edition, etc. would be. It's kind of unfair when you think about it.
---
SC2k4 Winner: Mega Man
Ken Masters; the fighting king clothed in blazing fire.
I was joking about MMAC. Although I do think that it could have taken Division 128 since it was so wide open. Also, last comment before I go lift weights, nobody has noted on the fact that the Spring Contest didn't have the same restrictions as the Summer Contests. Mainly, even though the characters had to originate from a video games, it didn't say that the GAMES had to be original right? Goldeneye got in..... So my question is....
*blatant plug*
Why weren't TMNT2: The Arcade Game and TMNTIV: Turtles in Time in the contest????
I'd pick both games to easily be in the top half of their divisions.... But maybe that's just me... <_<
---
"There are only 10 kinds of people in this world, those that read binary and those that don't."
Hm. I am curious what you guys think about my analysis. It will be in my next post. If it is received fairly well, I will make a topic.
---
The topic is dead. Not the kind of dead that can be cured with a Phoenix Down. I'm talking FMV sequence dead.- The King in Teal
Before I begin this analysis, I will provide all the past vote totals/percentages for any matches that Frog and Master Chief participated in.
Frog:
vs. Liquid Snake
Frog 50.05% 43913
Liquid Snake 49.95% 43820
TOTAL VOTES 87733
Well... He hasn't been in very many matches.
Master Chief:
vs. Felix
Master Chief 52.96% 56549
Felix 47.04% 50231
TOTAL VOTES 106780
vs. Aeris
Aeris Gainsborough 60.15% 65136
Master Chief 39.85% 43161
TOTAL VOTES 108297
vs. Crash Bandicoot
Master Chief 70.72% 54469
Crash Bandicoot 29.28% 22552
TOTAL VOTES 77021
As you can see, Master Chief has been in a fair few matches.
Now, as soon as the gates to this tournament were opened, everyone was overjoyed that local snub Frog had been included in the tournament. They were equally appauled that someone like MASTER CHIEF could POSSIBLY get the 3 seed. Of course, Frog immediately became the favorite to reach the sweet sixteen and lose to Solid Snake, though some risk takers put Frog past the Snake. However, few talked about Master Chief getting past Frog, assuming it was not even a plausible occurrence. Frog's first match against Liquid Snake was allegedly going to go off without a hitch seeing Frog the winner by a good 55%. Then, disaster struck. Frog vs. Liquid was a ridiculously CLOSE match, each competitor taking the lead then losing it just as fast. When the dust cleared, Frog was the victor, but not by nearly as much as expected. All the Frog supporters who had said the amphibian would destroy Liquid quickly retracted their statements and argued that Liquid was clearly a strong competitor.
Next up was the big MC. Master Chief, the very symbol of X-Box. Master Chief, the guy who had trouble dispatching Felix. Master Chief, who was never expected to perform well in ANY match after that. Master Chief who was so pathetic that he WHAT?!?! Master Chief who got 70% on Crash?!?! Yes, MC absolutely destroyed Crash, much to everyone's surprise. Of course, everyone immediately decided that this just meant Crash had taken a drastic fall this year, never attributing it to a Chief gain. And so the stage was set for the action-packed battle of Frog vs. Master Chief.
There are quite a few arguments that essentially give Frog this match before it even starts, and they seem flawless, at a glance at least. But upon further investigation of these claims, flaws are easily found. The most popular argument is probably the fact that Chrono Trigger recently got to the finals of the Best. Game. Ever. battle. They immediately assume that this is clear indication that Frog is a powerhouse just waiting to be seen in action. I have two words for you. Sarah. Kerrigan. Allow me to elaborate. I'm sure everyone is aware of Starcraft's surprise dominance in the Spring Contest. Unless you believe Sarah Kerrigan would be a powerful competitor in a Summer Contest atmosphere, you should know that characters and games are not interchangable. "But what about the power Crono and Magus constantly display?!?!?!" Crono is so powerful because the game has his name directly in the title (okay it's Chrono in the title but most people think Crono). Magus on the other hand, is a bad-ass mage who kicks ass, takes names, and drinks Duke Nukem. Frog, on my magical third hand, is just that. A frog. Unless you have played the game, you PROBABLY won't like Frog. Now let's examine Master Chief. There isn't much to say about him character-wise. Master Chief is, for all intents and purposes, X-Box. He is the very embodiment of the heavy system.
Another popular argument is "X-Box Hate". I will agree with you that there was X-Box hate last year. But between the first and second rounds of the Summer Contest, it already showed signs of diminishing. Master Chief went from 52% on Felix to 40% on AERIS, Queen of the Spoilers! From FF7, which had its two main characters duke it out in the finals last year. Say all you want but obtaining 40% against ANY FF7 character other than Cait Sith or Yuffie is no small feat. Some people may be saying, "So what? The X-Box hate went down a bit. It is probably still there for the most part." I am afraid I have to disagree with you. I present to you, the following proof:
Halo: Combat Evolved 49.83% 56258
Starcraft 51.17% 56631
TOTAL VOTES 112889
Again, Starcraft was quite the powerhouse in the Spring Contest, even going as far as defeating a Zelda game. Halo proved to be almost as powerful as Starcraft. X-Box hate? So last year. Then, as if he wanted to further solidify the fact that X-Box hate is dead, Master Chief absolutely obliterated Crash. I am sure many of you are saying, "Big deal. Washed up mascots don't make great testing dummies." Well, I will just tell you that Master Chief performed 6% better than expected.
A third argument which is shot down, rather quickly as well, is Master Chief's pathetic showing against Felix. This was most likely just a fluke. Master Chief DID go on to get 40% on Aeris shortly after his match with Felix, so this match was just an anomoly. One could say that Master Chief's fight with AERIS was the fluke, but that hardly makes sense when taking into account his performance against Crash. Now, I for one do NOT think that Frog would get any better than 43% on Aeris. "But MasterMage, that's 3% BETTER than the chief!!!! FISSION MAILED XDXD!!!" Ah, my fine feathered friend, that's where you are wrong. I firmly believe that Master Chief has gone up a sizable portion this year, within the range of getting 45% on Aeris now.
Now for the extra little things that could possibly give Master Chief a few votes here and there. Hype and Picture. I know, I know, "Hype does nothing," blah blah blah. Ordinarily, I'd agree. However, over 1,000,000 pre-orders tends to turn a few heads. People ARE thinking about Halo 2. And luckily for Master Chief, his match is a little before Halo 2 is released, therefore giving the game no time to disappoint anyone. Of course, I doubt it will be disappointing at all but still. And now, the ever mystical "picture advantage". I will say right now that picture advantage doesn't do much. However, IF it is a close match, the picture advantage takes a bit more meaning. Therefore, if this match turns out to be a nail-biter, MC may benefit from the fact that Frog has a terrible mug shot. After seeing the picture, I for one would not vote Frog if I had never heard of either character. One more factor that could come into play is that fact that many, MANY people absolutely love bees.
My prediction for this match is Master Chief with 52% of the votes. My bracket has Master Chief winning, as does my heart. If you actually took the time to read this, thank you, and I look forward to your ridicule.
Ah, I couldn't imagine a NES game winning the contest. Mario 3 is likely the strongest representative from the 8-bit era. Even at its strongest, it could only manage around 40% on Final Fantasy VII. I can't see an old game taking it down, or possibly even any new game. Zelda 10 would have to be better than Ocarina of Time in every conceivable way before it could win, and that's about the only game I could see getting it done. It wouldn't be out in time to be eligible for the next Spring Contest though.
---
Bomberman's Road to the Summer Championship
1st Round: (4)Squall Leonhart, 2nd Round: (5)Kirby
=(
Read my analysis ;-;
---
The topic is dead. Not the kind of dead that can be cured with a Phoenix Down. I'm talking FMV sequence dead.- The King in Teal
There's really not much reason to have another game contest. Certainly not every year.
---
SC2k4 Winner: Mega Man
Ken Masters; the fighting king clothed in blazing fire.
Master Chief who got 70% on Crash?!?!
That's really not that much of an accomplishment anymore. Plenty of reason for it to be attributed to Crash going down as opposed to it being Master Chief all going up.
---
SC2k4 Winner: Mega Man
Ken Masters; the fighting king clothed in blazing fire.
Eh, it could be somewhat more interesting if CJayC just mixed up the bracket at random and didn't have the generation rule for series. The winner would be obvious, but at least we could have some interesting matchups. Then we could retire the Spring Contest.
---
Bomberman's Road to the Summer Championship
1st Round: (4)Squall Leonhart, 2nd Round: (5)Kirby
Heh, Crash is another example of my fodder fluctuation theory. He performed at 2002 levels against Master Chief. I think the only reason he went up in strength last year was due to the opponent he faced. KOS-MOS is more of a cult character, so it would make sense that a mainstream platforming icon (even though he's nearly dead now) would overperform.
---
Bomberman's Road to the Summer Championship
1st Round: (4)Squall Leonhart, 2nd Round: (5)Kirby
Yeah, I don't know if the Spring Contest is going to be a staple thing, maybe something different this year for the spring, or maybe nothing for the spring. I don't see a different winner for the spring though, because it just doesn't seem that a game's popularity can really change much.
---
Today's Survivor topic can be found here, Please vote : )http://boards.gamefaqs.com/gfaqs/genmessage.php?board=8&topic=16070956
That's really not that much of an accomplishment anymore. Plenty of reason for it to be attributed to Crash going down as opposed to it being Master Chief all going up.
There is still reason to believe that X-Box hate diminished and that helps prove it. I was only using Crash to prove that point. If people really hate X-Box, why shouldn't they vote for Crash? Most people know who he is.
---
The topic is dead. Not the kind of dead that can be cured with a Phoenix Down. I'm talking FMV sequence dead.- The King in Teal
Again, Crash performed as he should have if he were still at 2002 levels against Master Chief, and he has a reasonable explanation to have supposedly gone up last summer. That overperformance was more Bandicoot than MC.
---
Bomberman's Road to the Summer Championship
1st Round: (4)Squall Leonhart, 2nd Round: (5)Kirby
I will cry if Frog loses.
He is my second favorite character, period. I love Halo, I read the books, I am going to a Midnight release party at my local EB for Halo 2, I think John AKA Master Chief is awesome. But Frog is....a Frog. And his theme kicks ass, if you don't think so I spit on you.
Go Frog!
---
SC2K4 Winner: Link defeats Sephiroth
SC2K4 Score: 42/44 (Yoshi) Pick: Frog
Ah, I couldn't imagine a NES game winning the contest. Mario 3 is likely the strongest representative from the 8-bit era. Even at its strongest, it could only manage around 40% on Final Fantasy VII. I can't see an old game taking it down, or possibly even any new game. Zelda 10 would have to be better than Ocarina of Time in every conceivable way before it could win, and that's about the only game I could see getting it done. It wouldn't be out in time to be eligible for the next Spring Contest though.
Agreed..
As for the analysis Mastermage gave, I thought it was well put and has good reasonings to why Master Chief can win. I agree with him and say Master Chief will win the match tomorrow even though my bracket has Frog as the victor. I might be totally off and say that Liquid is not that strong of a contender and that Frog is just way too hyped. We don't know much for these new characters as there is nothing we can base their strengths on. The question Heroic Mario was always asking is can you see a Master Chief > Liquid Snake victory? I can see it and that's why I am assuming Frog will lose tomorrow. I won't get my hopes up for tomorrow since as I have said before, the match can totally be a dud and either one can have a convincing win over the other.
---
SC2K4 Winner: Cloud Strife
Next Target: Vyse
I could see Master Chief beating Liquid Snake, and that's what's got me nervous about tomorrow's match. He's just like Tidus: He's a lot stronger than we give him credit for.
---
Bomberman's Road to the Summer Championship
1st Round: (4)Squall Leonhart, 2nd Round: (5)Kirby
I always could have seen Master Chief beating Liquid. I am sure a lot of other Frog supporters could have too, then changed their opinion as soon as Frog vs Liquid was close.
---
The topic is dead. Not the kind of dead that can be cured with a Phoenix Down. I'm talking FMV sequence dead.- The King in Teal
Eh, it could be somewhat more interesting if CJayC just mixed up the bracket at random and didn't have the generation rule for series.
It would be more interesting with that. Like you mentioned, the winner is still obvious and that makes the contest just a whole lot less interesting.
There is still reason to believe that X-Box hate diminished and that helps prove it.
There was never anything to pove that Xbox hate existed in the first place. It was just something that became more commonly accepted, much like Mario's anti-votes.
I was only using Crash to prove that point. If people really hate X-Box, why shouldn't they vote for Crash? Most people know who he is.
Why do they hate Xbox? There's never been anything to prove that they hated it in the first place and given the fact that Crash performed much more like a 2002 level and with nothing to possibly help him winning with 70% shouldn't send shockwaves through everyone.
---
SC2k4 Winner: Mega Man
Ken Masters; the fighting king clothed in blazing fire.